How a Missouri printer’s apprentice sounded the depths of a nation while making it laugh
Every country invents the writer it needs. America’s was a riverboat pilot who never finished school and spent much of his adult life broke. Samuel Langhorne Clemens—Mark Twain to everyone who mattered—built a career on the idea that the funniest thing about a nation is usually the thing it is most defensive about. That idea has aged rather well.
He was born in 1835 in Florida, Missouri, a village so small that Twain later joked he had increased its population by one percent merely by being born there. The family soon moved to Hannibal, on the Mississippi, where the boy absorbed two educations at once: the river, with its steamboats, slave auctions, and confidence men, and the print shop, where at 12 he learned to set other people’s words in type before he had any of his own worth setting. The pen name came later, borrowed from a boatman’s cry—“mark twain,” two fathoms of safe water—chosen, fittingly, by a man who spent his career testing how much depth a joke could hold before it ran aground on something serious.
Mileage as method
What made Twain different from other American humorists was mileage. He worked as a typesetter, a steamboat pilot, a failed prospector and a jobbing journalist, in Missouri, Nevada, California and points east, before turning himself loose on Europe and the Holy Land. The resulting travel books—The Innocents Abroad, Roughing It, Life on the Mississippi—are ostensibly about tourism. They are actually about provincialism, American and European alike, and Twain’s gift was to mock both without ever quite letting either side feel it had won. That instinct for puncturing complacency hardened, in later life, into something closer to activism. He joined the Anti-Imperialist League, denounced American conduct in the Philippines, and wrote with real fury about Belgian brutality in the Congo and about lynching at home. The white suit and the lecture-circuit charm made him beloved; the politics made him, for many of his admirers, considerably less comfortable to have at dinner. Twain seems to have preferred it that way.
Boys who see too much
His two best-known novels look, on their surface, like tales of boyhood truancy. The Adventures of Tom Sawyer is Twain in his lighter register, all pranks and stagecraft. Adventures of Huckleberry Finn, its wearier sequel, is something else entirely: a novel that uses a barely literate boy’s voice to stage the fiercest argument in American letters. When Huck decides to help Jim, an enslaved man, escape—resolving to “go to hell” rather than turn him in—Twain stages a small civil war between a child’s conscience and the moral instruction of his entire society. The conscience wins. That the book delivers this verdict in comic dialect, rather than sermon, is precisely what has kept it uncomfortable: banned from a Massachusetts library within a year of publication in 1885, and still argued over in American classrooms today. A novel that let readers relax about slavery would not have lasted this long.
Twain had a habit of supplying the label before anyone else noticed the pattern. The Gilded Age, co-written with Charles Dudley Warner in 1873, gave its name to an entire era of American speculation, corruption and thin varnish over shoddy timber—a title that has outlived the book itself. A Connecticut Yankee in King Arthur’s Court performs a related trick in reverse, sending a modern engineer back to Camelot to demonstrate that technology and democratic zeal, unaccompanied by wisdom, can be just as brutal as the feudalism they claim to improve on. Twain’s recurring suspicion, stated more bluntly elsewhere, was that in political matters human reasoning “is not above the monkey’s.” Progress, in his fiction, is never a straight line.
The private ledger
The public Twain—sold-out lecture halls, a syndicated wit, a white suit worn as a kind of uniform—obscured a private life that was considerably rougher. He sank a fortune into a doomed typesetting machine, went bankrupt, and spent years touring the world simply to pay off his creditors. He outlived three of his four children and his wife, Olivia. The later writing darkens accordingly, trading genial satire for something closer to despair about human folly. He never lost the jokes; he simply stopped pretending they were only jokes. “Whenever you find yourself on the side of the majority,” he wrote, “it is time to pause and reflect.” It reads like advice. It was closer to autobiography. Twain liked to note that he had arrived with Halley’s Comet in 1835 and predicted he would leave with it too. In 1910, as the comet swung back past Earth, he did.
He is sometimes called the father of American literature, a title that overstates the case if taken to mean he founded a school of writing. What he actually fixed was a register: vernacular, irreverent, congenitally suspicious of anyone in authority, willing to let a raft on the Mississippi carry arguments about race, empire, money and violence that more solemn prose would have struggled to smuggle past the censors. The tall tales and boyhood scrapes were never the point. They were the delivery mechanism.
That is the trick worth noticing, more than a century on: Twain did not resolve America’s contradictions, and had no interest in pretending he could. He made them legible instead, and arranged things so that readers laughed before they noticed what they had agreed to. Getting an argument past a reader’s defences while they are still smiling is a harder trick than writing a sermon. It is also, on the evidence, a more durable one.
Recommended Reading
0 comments