He wore cowboy boots but preferred bookshops to saddles, and while his prose evoked the American West, his pen often skewered its myths.
Larry McMurtry, the Pulitzer Prize-winning author who once declared fiction "a trivial art," spent his life in a paradox: writing masterful novels while claiming to despise them, amassing a vast personal library while dismissing book collecting as a "gentle madness," and chronicling the death of the American West even as he helped mythologize it.
Few writers have embodied such productive contradictions. McMurtry—a Texas-born intellectual who fled the ranch life only to spend decades memorializing it—produced over 30 novels, essays, and screenplays, ranging from elegiac Westerns like Lonesome Dove to scathing academic satires such as The Last Picture Show. His work was both a tribute to and a dissection of frontier mythology, delivered in prose as spare and unflinching as the landscapes he described. Beyond his fiction, he was a formidable literary critic, an obsessive bookseller (his store, Booked Up, housed over 400,000 volumes), and an unlikely Hollywood player, co-writing the screenplay for Brokeback Mountain. His legacy is that of a man who bridged high and low culture, reverence and irreverence, with equal parts wit and melancholy.
The Cowboy Who Read Proust
Born in 1936 in Archer City, Texas—a town he would later immortalize as "Thalia" in his fiction—McMurtry grew up in a family of cattle ranchers, a world he found both stifling and inescapable. "I didn’t want to be a cowboy," he once said. "I wanted to be a man of letters." A precocious reader, he devoured Marcel Proust and Wallace Stevens while still a teenager, an intellectual restlessness that led him to Rice University and later Stanford, where he studied under the famed critic Malcolm Cowley.
Yet the pull of Texas never fully left him. His early novels, Horseman, Pass By (1961) and Leaving Cheyenne (1963), grappled with the decline of the Old West, a theme that would dominate his career. Unlike the romanticized visions of Zane Grey or Louis L’Amour, McMurtry’s West was one of entropy—of dying towns, broken dreams, and cowboys who quoted poetry. His breakthrough, The Last Picture Show (1966), cemented his reputation as a chronicler of American disillusionment, its bleak humor and unsentimental gaze earning comparisons to Sherwood Anderson.
The Pulitzer and the Paradox of Lonesome Dove
In 1986, McMurtry published Lonesome Dove, an epic Western that won the Pulitzer Prize and became one of the most celebrated novels of the 20th century. Ironically, he had initially dismissed it as a "minor book," written partly to pay off debts from his book-collecting habit. A sprawling, picaresque tale of two aging Texas Rangers driving cattle to Montana, the novel was both a homage to and a subversion of Western tropes. Its heroes, Gus McCrae and Woodrow Call, were charismatic but flawed, their adventures tinged with futility.
The book’s success troubled McMurtry, who feared it overshadowed his more experimental works, like Moving On (1970) or Cadillac Jack (1982). Yet Lonesome Dove endured precisely because it transcended genre, blending myth and anti-myth in equal measure. Its influence extended beyond literature, shaping modern Westerns from Deadwood to No Country for Old Men.
The Anti-Literary Literary Man
McMurtry’s disdain for the pretensions of high literature was as legendary as his bibliomania. He called novels "a minor art form, like tapestry," preferring the immediacy of memoirs and biographies. His critical essays, collected in In a Narrow Grave (1968) and Walter Benjamin at the Dairy Queen (1999), argued that American fiction had grown insular, too obsessed with technique over storytelling.
Yet his own work was deeply literary, steeped in allusions to classical mythology and 19th-century realism. He admired Stendhal’s clarity and Proust’s psychological depth, even as he mocked MFA programs for producing "airless" fiction. This tension—between populism and erudition—made him a singular voice in American letters, one who could dismiss Ulysses as "unreadable" while crafting sentences of Jamesian precision.
The Bookseller of Archer City
In the 1970s, McMurtry embarked on a second career as a bookseller, founding Booked Up in Washington, D.C., before relocating it to Archer City. The store became a pilgrimage site for bibliophiles, its shelves groaning under first editions, rare manuscripts, and McMurtry’s own acquisitions (he once bought an entire bookstore’s stock on a whim). For him, bookselling was as vital as writing—a way to democratize literature.
Yet even here, his contradictions surfaced. He called book collecting "a harmless addiction," yet he owned over 28,000 volumes. He lamented the decline of independent bookstores while selling off parts of his own collection in later years. His memoir, Books (2008), captured this ambivalence, blending nostalgia with clear-eyed pragmatism about the publishing industry’s decline.
The Last Picture Show
McMurtry died in 2021, leaving behind a body of work that defies easy categorization. Was he a regionalist or a cosmopolitan? A traditional storyteller or a postmodern skeptic? His answer would likely have been a shrug. In the end, his greatest subject was the American capacity for self-mythology—and the inevitable comedown. As he wrote in Lonesome Dove: "The world would never be the same again, and the thought made him sad, though he knew it was foolish." Few writers have captured that foolish, necessary sadness so well.
Recommended Reading
0 comments